In their most recent article authored by Stefanie Kundakjian, Hye-Phen compares the current situation at Standing Rock Indian Reservation, where protests have erupted over an oil pipeline, to the the Armenian Genocide. The lines Kundakjian attempts to draw between the two events resemble a severe epileptic's connect the dots puzzle. Here are each of her arguments and why they are ignorant:
- "The ancient city of Samosata (in Armenian: Շամուշատ) was flooded by the Atatürk Dam"
- "Surp Giragos Armenian Apostolic Church in Diyarbakir has been expropriated"
- "Traces of old Yerevan are being demolished"
- "The old mining town of Alaverdi has become extremely cancerous"
Indeed, all of the events mentioned in the article are factual. Samosata was lost in 1989, and Surp Giragos (along with others) was expropriated by Turkish authorities in 2016. It is also true historical buildings are regularly demolished in Yerevan, and Alaverdi is an absolute mess. However, what is happening with the Dakota Access Pipeline is no way, shape, or form comparable to these.
The difference between these events is crystal clear for anyone with even a partially functioning frontal lobe:
- The path of the pipeline has been carefully selected in order to avoid harming any historic or spiritual sites, and the pipeline may be rerouted if other sites are identified
- The land being expropriated is being bought at a fair market value from the deed holders, in Turkey no one has been compensated and it's not only land but historical buildings
- No towns or cities are being disrupted by the pipeline
- Alaverdi is the result of loose or nonexistent regulations and outdated technology, while the pipeline is under strict regulation and being built with the newest technology and materials
It is also important to point out the difference between the governments of Turkey and the United States of America. The U.S.A. has recognized the atrocities committed against the Native Americans, provided the Natives self-governed land, and rights not available to other American citizens. While in Turkey the Armenian Genocide is violently denied by the government, outside of Istanbul Armenians still live in fear and are threatened, and not one area has been designated for Armenians on land that is rightfully ours. Also, expropriation in Turkey serves to erase evidence and invalidate Armenian land claims - something the pipeline is not attempting to do. The simple fact these protests and legal actions were even allowed to occur should provide further understanding as to why the two are so very different.
This is not he first time Hye-Phen has brought disgrace upon themselves and it won't be the last. Their addiction to "intersectionality" and "solidarity" has driven them to marginalize the Armenian Genocide and to treat its meaning with outright levity by making unjust comparisons. They are using the Armenian Genocide as a tool to push their agenda, something which should cause anger and offense in every Armenian. The Armenian Genocide is not a prop to be used on their stage of absurdity in order to add gravity to their otherwise featherweight notions.
This is not he first time Hye-Phen has brought disgrace upon themselves and it won't be the last. Their addiction to "intersectionality" and "solidarity" has driven them to marginalize the Armenian Genocide and to treat its meaning with outright levity by making unjust comparisons. They are using the Armenian Genocide as a tool to push their agenda, something which should cause anger and offense in every Armenian. The Armenian Genocide is not a prop to be used on their stage of absurdity in order to add gravity to their otherwise featherweight notions.
Hye-Phen really is the "Inter Semiotics"* of Armenian "journalism" - leftist, void of logic, commonsense, and reasoning. They should be ashamed of themselves for publishing such ludicrous pieces and we, as decent individuals, should take them to task for it. It's time for us to steamroll this monstrosity before it's allowed to spread its virus any further.
*Your disdain for the leftist millennials will increase
No comments:
Post a Comment